How do you know which trait is dominant?
You may also wish to consider this question:

How did scientists determine which trait is dominant in the first place?

This might be a good time to bring up the difference between determining which traits are dominant in humans and determining which traits are dominant in species in which mating or cross-pollinating experiments can be performed.   Consider the method by which Gregor Mendel discovered dominant and recessive characteristics.  He could selectively mate plants to generate the genotype he wished.  Instead of using mating experiments as Gregor Mendel did we can use a process called pedigree analysis in order to study human genetics.  In a way we will look backwards instead of forwards to determine what trait is dominant.

Have students work individually on this unless students do not have much access to parental information in which case working in groups of 2 or 3 will be satisfactory.  After defining a pedigree analysis and showing students an example of a flow chart, students should each receive a copy of the questions and be given time to complete the first 2 questions for a dominant and recessive trait that they have.  The next day students should be able to complete the rest of the assignment.

 
1.  Students should first select a trait from the one used in the Human Genetics project in which they have the recessive phenotype. 
2.  Students (as a class, group or individual) should hypothesize the phenotype of their parents (and grandparents if possible) and explain why.  Making a flow chart to visualize this is recommended.
3.  Students then determine the phenotype of their parents for homework.  If possible, determine the phenotype of grandparents as well. 
4.  Students can then determine if their hypothesis is correct and whether or not it fit their current knowledge of genetics and trait dominance.
5.  Repeat steps 1-4 for a trait in which the student exhibits the dominant phenotype.
Have students either present their findings to the class or submit a report.  They should submit the pedigree analysis along with answers to the following question:

From the work you have done putting together your pedigree, can you conclude for certain which trait is dominant?  Explain how you came to this conclusion.  If you failed to make any conclusion explain why you cannot make a conclusive statement.
 
Copyright © 2008 Stevens Institute of Technology,
Center for Innovation in Engineering and Science Education
All Rights Reserved